Testimonials
Contact Us


Experience innovation right here..

Systems Thinking, Powerful Conversations and Accelerated Innovation are three frames that JB Innovation offers to take you and your culture to the next level of innovation. The following puzzle and exploration through real world examples of thinking, communicating and coordinating action will help you to understand the power of innovation.

The Nine Dot Puzzle with a twist or two

Draw nine dots on a piece of paper arranged in a square like those below. Take a pen and without lifting it from the paper see how few straight lines you can draw to connect all the dots? Several solutions are provided with tips for you to create your own. How few straight lines can you use to connect your dots? Here is a 5-line solution.

 

 

 

 

A 5-line solution:

Can you find a 4-line solution? What if your organization's, community's, family's or personal future depended upon it? Think about your thinking. Be the observer of the way you observe the world. Challenge your assessments. What are the relationship between the elements of the system or problem? What is the role or purpose of each element in the system - the pen, the paper, the dots, the lines? What is the purpose of the system?

Here is a clue to a 4-line solution. Or, skip to a 4-line solution and also learn how different thinking can lead to profitable innovation in the real world.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

A clue to a 4-line solution to the Puzzle:

Change the relationship between two elements in the problem:
(1) The box formed by the dots and (2) your straight lines.. Here is a 4-line solution.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

A 4-line solution:

Many people make the assumption that you must stay within the box. As soon as you consider drawing your lines outside of the box, the following 4 line solution emerges. We have observed that this solution emerges quicker if you just put your pen to the paper and draw. We have also found that collaboration also accelerates innovation.

Here is the 4-line solution...

How could this apply to profitable innovation in the real world?
Or, skip to the next challenge in the puzzle

 

 

 

 

 

A real world example - Individual Innovation:

Creative thinking can be valuable for individuals. Scott now has a new career incorporating his passion and his strengths because in 2002 he imagined several possible futures for himself - some that seemed risky and even crazy. He shared his visions with others and many of the perceived conflicts and risks evaporated with these conversations. Discover the value of your ideas through conversations for understanding, possibilities and coordinated action.

See another example: Commentated Pictures can help share a vision
Or, skip to try a 3-line solution

 

 

 

 

A real world example: Commentated Art

Individual ideas are often useful for solving corporate puzzles. This vision of communication with a recorded commentary from the artist helped inspire others in the company to create a common vision for communication. The common vision is yielding great rewards for the organization.

Try a 3-line solution and learn more about innovation from real world examples.

 

 

 

 

 

Change your thinking again and try for a 3-line solution. Hint: Try changing the relationship between two other elements in the puzzle. Here is a tip and here is a 3-line solution.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Tip for a 3-line solution:

Consider the size of the dots in relation to the configuration of the dots.. Consider magnifying the size of the dots. What if the dots are not pin points, but are saucers?

Here is a 3-line solution.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

A 3-line solution:

By changing the relationship between the size of the dots and the size of the square a 3-line solution is found.

See a real world example of group innovation
And try for a 1-line solution

 

 

 

 

 

A real world example - Group Innovation:

The members of the collections department of a large financial services firm assumed that their target of generating $90 million in additional collections was almost impossible. Working together with stakeholders, applying a proven accelerated innovation process, including systems thinking, they surprised themselves by coming up with ideas for $240 million in new collections!

Try for a 1-line solution and also see an example of organizational innovation. Hint: Try changing the relationship between two other elements in the puzzle.
Here is a tip
and here is a 1-line solution

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Tip for a 1-line solution:

Consider adapting the relationship between the dots, keeping the shape, but changing their size.

Here is a 1-line solution:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

A 1-line solution:

Consider magnifying the size of the pen and then adapt the configuration of the dots: Draw the dots very small and very very close together. Then, draw one thick line through them with the thick pen!

That's stupid you say! We agree.
And often the best ideas at first seem ridiculous. Einstein said so.

See an example of organizational innovation and discover which was the best solution to the puzzle

 

 

 

 

 

 

A real world example - New Product Innovation:

An oil company searching for new products assumed that an artist who didn't drive a car could not be helpful in finding new oil products for cars. The company did not want the artist involved in a new product innovation workshop. In the end the artist was allowed to participate and she came up with an idea for a new oil for old cars. It is now a multi-million dollar product.

Which solution to the nine dot puzzle was the best?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Summing the experience up

We believe that any solution beyond the four-line solution (just "outside of the box") is great. We believe that the challenge is not to stop at the first answer we like, our boss or client likes. Go beyond "good." Search for ideal. We suggest that you first consider your ideal evaluation criteria and then through a process of seeking deep understanding of the system and considering new possibilities, come up with as many ideas as you can
before evaluating any
of them.
Initially, the oil for old cars idea mentioned above was considered quite crazy by the company employees themselves.
They laughed at it. This was an early clue to the potential value of the idea.

Congratulations! You made it through our puzzle and you practiced some systems thinking.
We hope that you had fun!

We think of questions and ideas like shots in sports: The only really bad shots are the ones not taken.
Similarly, we think the only bad questions or ideas are the ones not communicated.
Please ask us questions, give us ideas and send us your solutions to the nine dot puzzle.
Our aim is to help you succeed.

Back to top

 

The Process James Who? Contact Links Sounds Healthcare Innovation Financial Innovation Future Workshops Healthcare Innovation Financial Innovation Future Workshops